He Thought I'd Stay: His Mistake

Today was my four-year anniversary with Chace. He told me to wear my white dress for a surprise he had planned. I spent all afternoon getting ready, practicing my "Yes," certain he was finally going to propose.

But when I arrived at the hotel ballroom, the banner read, "Congratulations, Chace & Karyn."

In front of all their friends and family, he got down on one knee and proposed to his childhood friend, Karyn Warren.

He used his mother's heirloom ring—the one he once showed me, saying it was for the woman he would spend his life with.